Oh wow, pretty cool! i agree with pretty much everything. Also, I had not thought about that this way, but the thing about the YED's true form being that dark figure, it makes sense! That's why he bleed from *his* wrist, and infact that was his blood, not the host's.
""Anyway, the new information opens up the question again as to what exactly the YED’s endgame was and if Lilith plans tie in with them at all. If the YED’s plans were the same as Lilith’s, wouldn’t the angels know about it? Why did all of Mary’s friends have to die in order to cover the YED’s plans? What kind of threat did they pose?""
Ok, here I think Lilith and the YED are on opposite roads. Lilith wants to summon Lucifer, while I think the YED's purpose was to become someone who could rule hell, he's an ambitious lad ;) So I think their purposes never meet because the YED wouldn't want to raise something who is stronger than him would he?
And about Mary's friends, I thought that they probably had to die because they were family's friends and maybe hunters, you know? That would make sense. They posed a threat in that sense imo.
About the time travelling thing: it's obviously point 2 or 3 of the ones you write. I personally think that Castiel bends the time for him and allows him to see the truth because Castile himself *knows* Dean can't alter events as we know them. Otherwise it's obvious that Angels would have already gone back in time and modified the events and resolved a lot of issues, if they are smart *lol* About unchanging destiny, my opinion on the thing is that as Castiel says roads bring all to the same destination...this means that things that HAPPENED ALREADY can't be altered, so Mary has to die, etc...but things that have not happened YET can still be changed. So this means Sam can still choose the right thing. SPN's take on time travelling is different imo from Back To The Future, I think they assume that time goes forward and the present can't be changed modifying the past. There aren't parallel lines (realities) that co-exist in the past and can change the present and the future, I think in SPN time is a only line. This means that destiny is something that exists in the present and can still be decided in the future. So acording to my opinion, sam can still choose, and if he doesn't choose wisely there's no stopping him going back in time to fix things.
Oh dude, i love your reviews, can we be friends? :)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-10-11 03:45 pm (UTC)""Anyway, the new information opens up the question again as to what exactly the YED’s endgame was and if Lilith plans tie in with them at all. If the YED’s plans were the same as Lilith’s, wouldn’t the angels know about it? Why did all of Mary’s friends have to die in order to cover the YED’s plans? What kind of threat did they pose?""
Ok, here I think Lilith and the YED are on opposite roads. Lilith wants to summon Lucifer, while I think the YED's purpose was to become someone who could rule hell, he's an ambitious lad ;) So I think their purposes never meet because the YED wouldn't want to raise something who is stronger than him would he?
And about Mary's friends, I thought that they probably had to die because they were family's friends and maybe hunters, you know? That would make sense. They posed a threat in that sense imo.
About the time travelling thing: it's obviously point 2 or 3 of the ones you write. I personally think that Castiel bends the time for him and allows him to see the truth because Castile himself *knows* Dean can't alter events as we know them. Otherwise it's obvious that Angels would have already gone back in time and modified the events and resolved a lot of issues, if they are smart *lol*
About unchanging destiny, my opinion on the thing is that as Castiel says roads bring all to the same destination...this means that things that HAPPENED ALREADY can't be altered, so Mary has to die, etc...but things that have not happened YET can still be changed. So this means Sam can still choose the right thing.
SPN's take on time travelling is different imo from Back To The Future, I think they assume that time goes forward and the present can't be changed modifying the past. There aren't parallel lines (realities) that co-exist in the past and can change the present and the future, I think in SPN time is a only line. This means that destiny is something that exists in the present and can still be decided in the future. So acording to my opinion, sam can still choose, and if he doesn't choose wisely there's no stopping him going back in time to fix things.
Oh dude, i love your reviews, can we be friends? :)