I don't have much free time so I kinda lose track of reviews but your non-birthday mishap reminded me of the fact that I had missed some! I don't have much to add, I mostly agree with what you said. I do like Garth too, I like that he brings in some humor and that he genuinely seems to care about Sam and Dean. They need people like that in their lives (now let's just hope he doesn't get killed!). I'm slowly warming up to Amelia - I'm not totally there yet, but I'm interested in knowing more about her and her relationship with Sam (I think there's still more to know on that matter, especially on why they break up).