Wow, another surprise--you seemed to like it in your review! :s I'm surprised, since to me it felt like another BDABR-type epp, but for Dean instead of Sam (in that epp Dean wasn't really freaking out about Sam either)....

And meh, since he is supposed to be over-the-top anxious I didn't find it to be over-acting....the thing is I often feel freaked out by things jumping out on the show, and so I appreciated some acknowledgment of this--that "that was scary" (well usually, not the cat of course, that's to me akin to the pizza in MM)...:p And I'm so with Dean about not wanting to go into that building!