The current team of writers just doesn't seem to grasp the nuances in Dean's characters that always made him such a compelling and sympathetic figure.

I agree completely. Don't get me wrong, I do think that Dean can be manipulative and controlling to some extent, but he was never mean, and the current writing team doesn't balance his weaknesses with his strengths.

I've always liked both boys and was a big fan of the brother bond, but it's becoming harder all the time.